Post Class Post: Post Book Club Post

This last week’s class was book club week. We laughed, we ate cookies, we discussed. I really enjoyed the book club. Though I have no really studied English since high school (though I was a a history major in college), I have written seven novels for NaNoWriMo and love to discuss stories.

I really liked discussing “The Federalist Papers”. I felt like this was one of the densest readings and felt the discussion really helped understand it. I really liked the discussion of anonymity and whether we could have a ‘publius’ in our modern age. I also liked the discussion of Bananafish, though it was last, because I had not read any of the author’s work in high school so the “experts” who had read it before were especially useful. It was also very interesting hearing people’s different reactions to the interaction between the little girl and husband. It was very interesting to see how so many people were interpret the same situation. The discussions about death got a little heavy at times, but I liked that people were applying the book club discussion so much to their own lives. I also liked the cookies, but that goes without saying.

Having never done any sort of formal book discussion where I was “teacher” before, it was an interesting experience overall. I can see many applications for this exercise outside of fiction discussion. For example, in business libraryland, a common information literacy competency is the ability to interpret annual reports. You could have a group of student read four annual reports from four different companies. Students could compare and contrast how the companies present themselves in those papers. The book club format of smaller groups and sets of questions for discussion could be very useful in this case.


About Ilana the Librarian

I am an aspiring librarian at the University of Michigan.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized. Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Post Class Post: Post Book Club Post

  1. adamsliz says:

    I really like your idea of book groups in business libraryland! In Mary’s blog, I mentioned that I really liked her use of the word “casual” in regards to the structuring of book clubs. Interpreting annual reports seems like a really nerve-racking process. What if I’m wrong? What if the company loses money because of me? In a more “casual” setting like a book club, I think some of that pressure would be alleviated. Book clubs have certain connotations, and in the case of annual reports, I believe that those connotations and its more casual nature could provide outlets for learning and engaging with unfamiliar topics.

    • Annual Reports are actually not scary. They are just yearly reports that businesses put out to stakeholders about the state of the company. There are many glossy pictures and few charts. They are actually kind of fun to real! But they are also, being from the company’s perspective, incredibly biased. Looking at a group of them in a casual manner would allow students to really realize how different these reports are and how biased they can be.

  2. Kristin says:

    I like the idea of compare/contrast. Also, congrats on NaNoWriMo! I’ve always wanted to do that, but October-November is conference season, and there’s tons going on!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s